Join Books.org — it's free

Opera - General & Miscellaneous, Musical Theater/Broadway
Believing in Opera by Tom Sutcliffe β€” book cover

Believing in Opera

by Tom Sutcliffe
Write a review
Log in to track your reading progress.

Overview

The staging of opera has become immensely controversial over the last twenty years. Tom Sutcliffe here offers an engaging and far-reaching book about opera performance and interpretation. This work is a unique tribute to the most distinctive and adventurous achievements in the theatrical interpretation of opera as it has developed in recent decades. Readers will find descriptions of the most original and successful avant-garde opera productions in Britain, Europe, and America. Sutcliffe beautifully illustrates how updating, transposition, or relocation, and a variety of unexpected imagery in opera, have qualified and adjusted our perception of the content and intention of established masterpieces.

Believing in Opera describes in detail the seminal opera productions of the last fifty years, starting with Peter Brook in London after the war, and continuing with the work of such directors and producers as Patrice ChΓ©reau in Bayreuth, Peter Sellars and David Alden in America, Ruth Berghaus in Frankfurt, and such British directors as Richard Jones, Graham Vick, Peter Hall, and David Pountney. Through his descriptions of these works, Sutcliffe states that theatrical opera has been enormously influenced by the editing style, imagery, and metaphor commonplace in the cinema and pop videos. The evolution of the performing arts depends upon revitalization and defamiliarization, he asserts. The issue is no longer naturalism, but the liberation of the audience's imagination powered by the music.

Sutcliffe, an opera critic for many years, argues that opera is theater plus music of the highest expressive quality, and as a result he has often sided with unconventional and novel theatrical interpretations. He believes that there is more to opera than meets the ear, and his aim is to further the process of understanding and interpretation of these important opera productions. No other book has attempted this kind of monumental survey.

Reviews

There are no reviews yet. Log in to write one.

Editorials

Publishers Weekly - Publisher's Weekly

After a brief career as a countertenor, Sutcliffe settled into a 24-year stint as opera critic at the Guardian before moving on to the same position at the Evening Standard. Whatever is implied by the title, this is in fact an overlong homage to certain contemporary opera directors. Sutcliffe examines big names such as Peter Sellars, Ruth Berghaus and Graham Vick as well as Patrice Chreau, although the French director's career in opera has been intermittent at best. On the other hand, the Italians Luchino Visconti and Giorgio Strehler get short shrift, perhaps because he hasn't seen as many of their productions. Sutcliffe's musical judgments are sometimes inadequate, such as when he calls Olivier Messaien's musical language nave. Messaien, a professor at the Paris Conservatoire, was ponderous and abstruse but hardly nave. Sutcliffe does make a number of good points: for example, the sheer theatrical variety of opera means it can never be ideal for the small TV screen. But he also seems conflicted about the basic issue of making opera accessible. On the one hand, he overrates Peter Brook's abridged versions of Carmen and Pellas and Mlisande, which made mincemeat of the music (mainly because Sutcliffe appears to care more about drama than about music), and objects to the Paris Bastille Opra's hiring of Daniel Barenboim, "an elitist career musician with no commitment to vernacular opera or egalitarian theater" (without naming the paragon who might be the alternate choice). On the other hand, he claims that the installation of surtitles at the New York City Opera "will surely prove a damaging development for the future of opera and singing in the U.S." Better editing would have spared readers unhelpful digressions in what is otherwise a valid recounting of operagoing, with the stage director as key player. (Feb.)

Library Journal

Sutcliffe brings his long association with opera as both performer and critic (for the Guardian and the Evening Standard) to this exploration of the opera productions he considers most interesting or innovative. Star performers take a back seat here. Instead, Sutcliffe uses his extraordinarily wide experience of opera productions (especially those in Britain and Europe from the mid-Seventies to the present) to portray the producer as central in the process of renewal, creativity, and even controversy that is essential for a healthy, evolving opera. The influences on opera production of changing technology in other fields of entertainment, including film and video, are evident. Sutcliffe definitely offers a fresh perspective, leaving the reader with a good awareness of the course of recent opera production. Some will be stimulated to think of new possibilities. Recommended for larger opera collections, especially those serving areas in which opera production is of interest.James E. Ross, WLN, Seattle, Wash.

Book Details

Published
February 1, 1997
Publisher
Princeton, N.J. : Princeton University Press ; c1996.
Pages
480
Format
Hardcover
ISBN
9780691015637

More by Tom Sutcliffe

Similar books