Civil War soldiers

Publishers Weekly - Publisher's Weekly

This noteworthy addition to the literature of the Civil War presents a starkly realistic picture, mostly from the lower ranks, that is reminiscent of the outlook of GIs in more recent wars. The prevailing image of the enemy: an uncivilized fanatic. Civilians of the opposing side were regarded as primitive, ignorant and generally contemptible. Based on unpublished letters and diaries, Mitchell's study follows Union troops into the South (Sherman in Georgia, for instance) and the Confederate army in the North (Lee's invasion of Pennsylvania), showing that the men of both armies were offended by the behavior of noncombatant civilians, that medical support was abominable, that blacks suffered brutality from soldiers of both armies and that the temptation to desert was strong. Among the themes explored by Mitchell are the individual's reasons for volunteering, his reaction to combat, his perception of the similarity between soldiering and slavery, the morale-sustaining comfort of Christian faith, and the bravery and endurance of the Confederate soldier in particular. Mitchell teaches American history at Princeton. (August)

Library Journal

With a ``post-Vietnam'' sensitivity to how combat and military discipline transform common folk into soldiers, Mitchell (American history, Princeton) offers the most original reading of Civil War soldiers since Bell Wiley's classics The Life of Johnny Reb (Bobbs, 1943) and The Life of Billy Yank (Bobbs, 1952). Mitchell finds a higher degree of ideological commitment by both Rebs and Yanks than have other scholars, but his main contribution is showing how soldiers' reactions to such aspects as drill and death and land revealed a common American heritage and values shared by both sides, even as the war continued. This book makes all those statues in town squares come alive. Randall M. Miller, St. Joseph's Univ., Philadelphia

Booknews

Both sad and humorous. A look at the Civil War soldier's beliefs, goals, and fears. Annotation c. Book News, Inc., Portland, OR (booknews.com)