Overview
"[This book] It is provocative and bold. Brass bases his theories on his rather extensive study of the historical and political processes in multi-ethnic societies, especially India. There is much truth in his identification of the problem in the state of Punjab and elsewhere in India, in relentless centralization and, often, some questionable interventionist policies of the central government. "
—International Migration Review
"Ethnicity and Nationalism is most timely and relevant. . . . This book offers many positives. It is provocative and bold. Paul Brass bases his theories on his rather extensive study of the historical and political processes in multiethnic societies, especially in India. There is much truth in his identification of the problem in the state of Punjab and elsewhere in India. "
—International Migration Review
"The present volume is a very important contribution toward the study of ethnicity and nationalism. The book would be of interest to a wide range of scholars, particularly those with a South Asian focus. "
—Asian and Pacific Migration Journal
"This volume is a very important contribution toward the study of ethnicity and nationalism. The book would be of interest to a wide range of scholars, particularly those with a South Asian focus. "
—Asia and Pacific Mirgration Journal Ethnicity and nationalism, interethnic conflicts, and secessionist movements have been major forces shaping the modern world and the structure and stability of contemporary states. In the closing decades of the twentieth century, such forces and movements have emerged with new intensity. Drawing his examples in this major study from a wide variety of multiethnic situations around the world, with special emphasis on South Asia, Eastern Europe, and the Soviet Union, Paul Brass presents a distinctive theory concerning the origins of ethnic identity and modern nationalism.
The author bases his theory on two focal arguments: one, that ethnicity and nationalism are not "givens," but are social and political constructions. The second is that ethnicity and nationalism are modern phenomena inseparably connected with the activities of the modern centralizing state.
Examples and case studies from India comprise the heart of this volume. Three chapters focus specifically on two minority groups in India: north India Muslims and the Sikhs of Punjab. A second and substantial source of illustrations, which substantiate the theoretical arguments, is Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union. The author also presents a direct comparison of language-based ethnic problems in India and the Soviet Union.
An original perspective on the major themes and arguments concerning ethnicity and nationalism, this book is essential reading for scholars and academics in the fields of ethnic studies, comparative politics, development studies, and anthropology.
"Brass's work is a significant contribution to the study of ethnicity and nationalism. His work draws our attention to the complexity of the politics of identity. Students of Indian politics will find the book extremely useful and the people who in recent years are trying to invent a primordial basis for the Indian nation will find it disconcerting. "
—The Indian Economic and Social History Review
"This timely volume....will be of considerable interest to students of South Asian politics for its clarity and commitment. "
—International Journal of Punjab Studies
"When a major writer shifts the focus on his inquiry, it becomes the cause of a certain excitement within the discipline as a whole. Such is the case with Ethnicity and Nationalism where Paul Brass, long a familiar name for students of Indian politics, questions the applicability of the consociational model as an effective method of achieving democratic political order in multi-ethnic societies. "
—Journal of Commonwealth and Comparative Politics
"This is a useful book for it brings together Paul Brass' writings on the subject of ethnicity and politics between 1978 and 1990. "
—Contributions to Indian Sociology
"By virtue of the theoretical and empirical assertions it makes and the political controversy it is bound to give rise to, Ethnicity and Nationalism is an important addition to Indian and comparative politics. The book can be read with profit. "
—Journal of Commonwealth and Comparative Politics
"This is a valuable addition to the literature on ethnicity and nationalism. But more than just an addition, it illumines the multi-layered social grid in multi-ethnic societies consisting of majorities and minorities, conflicts of interests, and the key role played by both the State and various elites in the formation of ethnicity and nationalism. "
—Media Development
Editorials
From the Publisher
'an elaborate and valuable analysis of...tension between class and ethnicity. At another level, he also explores the relationship between ethnicity and other multi-class formations, the most important of which is 'nation'. The significance of the present book by Paul Brass, which takes his earlier writings forward, is that it examines the elements of this confrontation between 'class' and 'nation' and 'ethnicity' in the Indian context.' - Seminar'This will remain an important contribution to the study of modern social formations.' - SABRS
'Seeing Brass's stature, the book is bound to become essential reading for senior scholars of ethnicity, nationalism and politics, as it does add one dimension to various sophisticated studies on nationalism.' - Financial Express
'Brass's book is a timely one. It both encourages us to believe that we have not passed the point of no return and suggests ways by which we can clamber back to firm ground.' - Indian Review of Books
'admirable, well-researched analysis.... This is a valuable addition to the literature on ethnicity and nationalism. But more than just an addition, it illuminates the multi-layered social grid in multi-ethnic societies consisting of majorities and minorities, conflicts of interests, and the key role played by both the State and various elites in the formation of ethnicity and nationalism.' - Media Development
'To Paul Brass's credit, unlike some other distinguished authors of such volumes as this, he has done a good deal of work in revising and updating the papers, and in making connections between them.' - Third World Quarterly
'When a major writer shifts the focus of his inquiry, it becomes the cause of a certain excitement within the discipline as a whole. Such is the case with Ethnicity and Nationalism...By virtue of the theoretical and empirical assertions it makes and the political controversy it is bound to give rise to, Ethnicity and Nationalism is an important addition to Indian and comparative politics. The book can be read with profit both by those who specialise in the study of South Asia, as well as the general reader...provides the necessary first steps for a general theory of ethnicity and competitive politics' - Journal of Commonwealth & Comparative Politics