Jesus' Directions for the Future, Vol. 9

Michael Luper

...McNicol's work provides significant support for the idea of a common eschatological tradition behind the Thessalonian correspondence and the last eschatological discourse of Jesus....perhaps its most significant contribution is found in the fact that it provides the most detailed analysis to date dealing with such an extensive set of Synoptic texts from the perspective of Matthean priority; and those interested in source criticism will certainly want to consider McNicol's work...whether or not they are convinced by his arguments.
—Society of Biblical Literature

Michael Luper

...McNicol's work provides significant support for the idea of a common eschatological tradition behind the Thessalonian correspondence and the last eschatological discourse of Jesus....perhaps its most significant contribution is found in the fact that it provides the most detailed analysis to date dealing with such an extensive set of Synoptic texts from the perspective of Matthean priority; and those interested in source criticism will certainly want to consider McNicol's work...whether or not they are convinced by his arguments.
— Society of Biblical Literature