Menachem Begin

School Library Journal

Gr 6-9-In a series foreword, Arthur Schlesinger establishes two tests of what constitutes "great leadership": whether leaders lead by force or by persuasion, and "the end for which power is sought." Judged by these two criteria, both Begin and Arafat as presented here fall far short of greatness (for different reasons). Though both of the authors poke occasional criticism at their subject, the overall tone of both books is laudatory. Brackett concentrates on Begin's reaction to the Holocaust, his involvement with Zionism in pre-Israeli Palestine, and his participation in Israeli politics until his resignation as prime minister in 1983. Williams traces Arafat's unhappy childhood in Egypt and later in Jerusalem; his gradual involvement with the Mufti of Palestine, who was granted asylum in Egypt after supporting Hitler in World War II; Arafat's leadership of al-Fatah and its eventual merger with the PLO; and his chairmanship of the Palestinian Authority. The book on Begin is the more cohesively written of the two, but each volume glosses over large areas of its subject's political life-the late 1960s and early 1970s of Begin's career and his postretirement life and the 1970s to 1990s in Arafat's life. Almost a whole chapter in Arafat is given over to large excerpts from his partisan speech to the U.N. in November 1974 and contains little contextual information for readers to judge the importance or accuracy of his comments. Each book has clear, color photos; a small map that is difficult to decipher; an incomplete index; and suggestions for further reading that list mainly adult books.-Jack Forman, Mesa College Library, San Diego Copyright 2003 Cahners Business Information.