Overview
The idea of evolution: it fascinates some of us, disturbs others, and leaves only a very few people indifferent. In a major new interpretation of evolutionary theory, Michael Ruse pinpoints the common source of this attraction and discomfort. A renowned writer on evolutionary theory and its history, Ruse has long been sensitive to the fact that many people—and not simply religious enthusiasts—find something deeply troubling about much of what passes for science in evolutionary circles. What causes this tension, he finds in his search of evolutionism's 250-year history, is the intimate relationship between evolution and the secular ideology of progress.
Ubiquitous in Darwin's time, the idea of an unceasing improvement in life insinuated its way into evolutionary theory from the first. In interviews with today's major figures in evolutionary biology—including Stephen Jay Gould, Edward O. Wilson, Ernst Mayr, and John Maynard Smith—and in an intimate look at the discoveries and advances in the history and philosophy of science, Ruse finds this belief just as prevalent today—however it might be denied or obscured. His book traces the delicate line between those who argue that science is and must be objective and those who deem science a "social construction" in the fashion of religion or the rest of culture. It offers an unparalleled account of evolutionary theory, from popular books to museums to the most complex theorizing, at a time when its status as science is under greater scrutiny than ever before.
Editorials
Library Journal
Evolution has stirred heated social debate from before the time of Darwin to the present, perhaps especially today. Ruse, a philosopher of bioethics and evolutionary biology at the University of Guelph, Ontario, discusses the influence of biological and social progressionist thought on the primary figures in the development of evolutionary theory. He also explores the role of progress in the development of the discipline from popular to professional science. Ruse confines himself to the biological realm of evolution and avoids the evolution vs. creation debate. From historical research to interviews with today's leading evolutionary biologists, Ruse's book mirrors the lively debates throughout the history of the field. Though not necessarily designed for general audiences, this thought-provoking and readable book is highly recommended for larger general as well as advanced undergraduate collections.-Bruce D. Neville, Univ. of New Mexico Lib., AlbuquerqueBooknews
Ruse (philosophy and zoology, U. of Guelph, Ontario) provides an intimate look at the relationship between evolutionary theory and the secular ideology of progress, a notion of unceasing improvement in life which has insinuated its way into evolutionary theory since Darwin's time. Annotation c. by Book News, Inc., Portland, Or.American Scientist
Michael Ruse has written an important book on the status of evolutionism that will almost certainly become embroiled in controversy.— Peter J. Bowler
Boston Book Review
[A] fascinating, and often maddening book...[Ruse] traces the history of evolutionary thought from Aristotle to Stephen Jay Gould and E. O. Wilson...[Ruse's book] gives us much to think about: the concept of evolution and the evolution of concepts, progress in nature and the nature of progress.— Lucy Horwitz
British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
Monad to Man will be controversial not because of its implications for social and ethical issues, but because of what it says about the scientific study of evolutionary biology...Ruse's writing style is bluff, unselfconscious, and opinionated...[It] does detract from the appearance of neutrality. But it adds immeasurably to the literary value of the book. Monad to Man combines the sweeping history of the science of evolution with intricate details about individual scientists' researches, prejudices, and personal lives...The result is a richly textured narrative...Ruse has certainly established that the ideas of evolution and progress have been closely linked. His thesis that the profession of biology has been shaped by scientists' embarrassment about this linkage will be the focus of further debate. In the meantime he has given us a rich and compelling narrative of the personalities and ideas that shaped the history of evolutionary biology.— Ron Amundson
Nature
Ruse provides a history of evolutionary biology from its inception to its belated maturity that is full of insight.— David L. Hull
New Scientist
What is your favourite model of biological evolution? Whether it is rungs on a ladder, the ever-branching tree, or even the more modern image of movement between peaks in a 'fitness landscape', chances are it treats time in just one way: later means better...The idea of evolution was the child of the hopes of progress, as Michael Ruse puts it in Monad to Man, his impressive 'philosophical history' of these notions...Ruse tracks down [this] tendency in the work of innumerable writers...All this makes [his] book a superb summary of the views of every major evolutionist. The result is unfailingly interesting. Ruse presents much to argue with, both for aficionados of evolution and for theorists of science.— Jon Turney
Northeastern Naturalist
Based on comparisons of professional and popular literature and interviews with leading theoreticians, this book presents a thorough overview and synthesis of evolutionary biology. Of significant heuristic value in the debate of the Western predeliction for the concept of progress as it applies to evolutionary theory. Sensitive to concerns of many non-scientists for the science of evolutionary biology. Extensive literature cited section. Very detailed and interesting accounts of the many people who have contributed to science of evolutionary biology.Nuncius [Italy]
The historical and conceptual richness of Ruse's treatment makes it inspiring reading. The book is not intended as a definitive history of evolutionary science. Rather it is a kaleidoscope of events and reflections meant to suggest new questions and inspire further research.— Nils Roll-Hansen
Toronto Globe & Mail
What Ruse produces is a grand review, an interesting and informative survey.— Arthur B. Cody
Washington Times
With verve, humor and much historical color, [Ruse] traces the conflict between the popular conception of evolution and the professionally legitimate version.— Jeffrey Marsh