Publishers Weekly - Publisher's Weekly
This disjointed narrative mixes an analysis of photography and the movies with a comparison of television coverage of the 1968 and 1988 presidential campaigns. Freelance writer Adatto interviewed numerous television journalists to show how image-making has supplanted hard issues as a topic for coverage and how media advisers have become a new pundit class. Her discussion of journalistic self-criticism suffers, however, from her concentration on 1988, not 1992. She then ranges afield, finding the roots of ``picture-centured journalism'' in newspaper photography of the 19th century and tracing current consciousness of images to movies and photographs that saw the television set as part of the ``social landscape.'' The lengthy concluding chapter summarizes portrayals of heroes in a range of American movies; in an epilogue, Adatto suggests that politicians seek to embrace the image of the maverick movie hero. Photos not seen by Publishers Weekly. (Apr.)
Library Journal
With the recent election and its media coverage fresh in our minds, Adatto, who writes about popular culture for the New Republic and other publications, offers us a critical framework for reconsidering the power of images in the political process. In her examination of the ``rise of a new image consciousness,'' Adatto finds connections among television news, art photography, and popular movies. She watched videotapes of the three major networks' news coverage of the 1968 and 1988 elections, interviewed media personnel and political participants, and viewed popular movies made from 1968 to 1992. Even though journalists have become sophisticated in reporting on the manipulation of images, their critical commentary has not undercut the power of these images. Adatto traces this power to the use of photographic images and film in popular culture. This provocative book should promote discussion and belongs in academic and large public libraries.-- Judy Solberg, Univ. of Maryland Libs., College Park
Booknews
Traces the rise of our "image-conscious" society and offers a fascinating discussion of how this society is moved to buy and vote by images. Based on hundreds of interviews with newscasters, political consultants and others, the text illustrates how images influence our thinking and how that effect is exploited by media, marketers, and politicians. Annotation c. Book News, Inc., Portland, OR (booknews.com)
Gilbert Taylor
This author slices off a narrow slice of modern propaganda, TV news coverage of presidential campaigns. The networks make millions off it from ad revenue; candidates gripe about it; and academics critique it. Adatto assumes the passivity of viewers, though he grants them a modicum of image-conscious sophistication. It's their bovine inability to distinguish the real from the artificial that so irks her, and to illustrate she compares a supposedly golden age of TV news--the 1968 presidential contest--with the 1988 edition. Where Walter and Chet gave the aspirants a minute of speech, Dan and Peter gave them five seconds. Reporters have evolved into snide theater critics. Tiresome lamentations indeed. Yet the fallen state has its defenders, and Adatto quotes their rationales, too. Her own unique way of getting through the miasma, hearkening back to the couch potatoes' common frame of reference, springs from the movies. In the maverick icons of cinema she somehow perceives the same confusion between reality and artificiality that Americans labor under as targets of televised politics. One-third of the book thus summarizes "Dirty Harry", "JFK", etc. The influence of advertising seems a less errant tangent to pursue, but at least this book projects some light (as an adjunct to "How to Watch TV News" by Postman ) on the silly telly.