Join Books.org — it's free

Logic, Logic & Foundations of Mathematics, Epistemology (Theory of Knowledge), History of Philosophy, 18th Century German Philosophy - Kant
Real Existence, Ideal Necessity : Kant's Compromise, and the Modalities Without the Compromise by Robert Greenberg — book cover

Real Existence, Ideal Necessity : Kant's Compromise, and the Modalities Without the Compromise

by Robert Greenberg
Available on Bookshop Write a review

Books.org participates in affiliate programs including Bookshop.org and the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page, at no additional cost to you.

Log in to track your reading progress.

Synopsis

Analytic philosophy has leveled many challenges to Kant's ascription of necessary properties and relations to objects in his Critique of Pure Reason. Some of these challenges can be answered, it is argued here, largely in terms of techniques belonging to analytic philosophy itself, in particular, to its philosophy of language. This Kantian response is the primary objective of this book. It takes the form of a compromise between the real existence of the objects that we can intuit and that get our knowledge started - dubbed initiators - and the ideality of the necessary properties and relations that Kant ascribes to our sensible representations of initiators, which he entitles appearances. Whereas the real existence of initiators is independent of us and our senses, the necessity of these properties and relations of appearances is due to their origins in the mind.
The Kantian compromise between real existence and ideal necessity is formulated in terms of David Kaplan's interpretation of de re necessity in his article, "Quantifying In" - his response to Quine's concern that a commitment to such a necessity leads to an acceptance of an unwanted traditional Aristotelian essentialism.
In addition, the book first abstracts and then departs from its interpretation of Kant to provide a realistic account of the relation between existence and de re necessity.

Reviews

There are no reviews yet. Log in to write one.

Book Details

Published
October 30, 2008
Publisher
De Gruyter, Walter, Inc.
Pages
211
Format
Hardcover
ISBN
9783110206906

More by Robert Greenberg

Similar books