Join Books.org — it's free

United States History - 20th Century - 1901 to 1945, Executive Branch, United States History - 20th Century - Wars & Conflict, U.S. - Political Biography, U.S. Politics - History, World War II, U.S. International Relations
The New Dealers' war by Thomas Fleming β€” book cover

The New Dealers' war

by Thomas Fleming
Write a review
Log in to track your reading progress.

Overview

Acclaimed historian Thomas Fleming brings to life the flawed and troubled FDR who struggled to manage WWII. Starting with the leak to the press of Roosevelt's famous Rainbow Plan, then spiraling back to FDR's inept prewar diplomacy with Japan, and his various attempts to lure Japan into an attack on the U.S. Fleet in the Pacific, Fleming takes the reader inside the incredibly fractious struggles and debates that went on in Washington, the nation, and the world as the New Dealers, led by FDR, strove to impose their will on the conduct of the War. Unlike the familiar yet idealized FDR of Doris Kearns Goodwin's No Ordinary Time, the reader encounters a Roosevelt in remorseless decline, battered by ideological forces and primitive hatreds which he could not handle-and frequently failed to understand-some of them leading to unimaginable catastrophe. Among FDR's most dismaying policies, Fleming argues, were an insistence on "unconditional surrender" for Germany (a policy that perhaps prolonged the war by as many as two years, leaving millions more dead) and his often uncritical embrace of and acquiescence to Stalin and the Soviets as an ally.For many Americans, Franklin Delano Roosevelt is a beloved, heroic, almost mythic figure, if not for the "big government" that was spawned under his New Deal, then certainly for his leadership through the War. The New Dealers' War paints a very different portrait of this leadership. It is sure to spark debate.

Reviews

There are no reviews yet. Log in to write one.

Editorials

From Barnes & Noble

Thomas Fleming, the author of Duel, turns his attention to the WWII policies of President Franklin Delano Roosevelt. In this controversial study, Fleming contends that FDR's insistence on Germany's unconditional surrender prolonged the global struggle for at least a year, and possibly two, at the cost of tens of thousands of lives. A revisionist view certain to gain media attention.

Washington Post

The book is a gripping, controversial, informative and at times infuriating look at FDR's leadership as the nation entered and fought World War II. Fleming obviously knows his stuff. The evidence he assembles seems authoritative, irrefutable and has seldom been gathered in one volume.

Publishers Weekly - Publisher's Weekly

Fleming, who previously endeavored to rehabilitate the villainous Aaron Burr in Duel, now attempts even more absurd revisionism. Franklin Roosevelt has been lauded by most historians most brilliantly by Eric Larrabee in his book Commander in Chief (1987) as a shrewd political and military strategist who conducted both aspects of WWII with great guile, wit and efficiency. Fleming, however, portrays FDR as an inefficient and oafish warmonger spoiling for battle amid world political, economic and social tensions he did not understand. Fleming revives the well-worn canard that FDR wanted, needed and invited the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. Then he quibbles with the notions of "unconditional surrender" and "total war" imposed on the Axis powers, speculating that some compromise should have been reached. Fleming fails to see what Roosevelt and Churchill (who called him "the most skilled strategist of all") clearly did that Hitler and his allies represented not just standard political and military aggression but a new dark age. Fleming implies that Stalin posed an even larger threat to culture and history, but that the left-wingers of Roosevelt's New Deal government were not disposed to see his evil. In truth, Roosevelt had few illusions when it came to the Soviets. Realizing their potential to be either formidable foes or formidable friends, he chose the latter at the same time reminding the sometimes disapproving Churchill that one occasionally needed to fight fire with fire. Photos not seen by PW. (May 1) Forecast: The controversy that will undoubtedly ensue on this book's publication should drive sales up. Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information.

Booknews

A historian and prolific writer, Fleming has turned his attention in this volume to the role of Roosevelt in WWII. The result is a revision of earlier histories as Fleming examines, in detail and at length, the history of the New Dealers' actions during the war. He draws on archival material for his information, including the personal accounts of people in Roosevelt's administration and contemporary newspaper accounts, as well as secondary sources. Annotation c. Book News, Inc., Portland, OR (booknews.com)

Book Details

Published
July 1, 2001
Publisher
New York : Basic Books, c2001.
Pages
640
Format
Hardcover
ISBN
9780465024643

More by Thomas Fleming

Similar books