Publishers Weekly
- Publisher's Weekly
Subtle and stirring, this tale-within-a-tale begins with an affectionate exchange between an African American girl and her grandmother, then telescopes to encompass an electrifying moment fraught with personal and political significance. Grandma tells of sneaking off to town one sizzling summer day when she was a child, "planning on doing no good." Approaching a water fountain, the thirsty girl mistakes its "Whites Only" sign to mean that she should take off her shoes so that only her white socks will touch the step stool. A "big white man" grabs her and removes his belt to whip her-prompting African American bystanders to remove their shoes, too, and defiantly drink from the fountain. At home, the narrator's mother proclaims she can now go to town by herself, " 'cause you're old enough to do some good"; in town, "the `Whites Only' sign was gone from that water fountain forever." Though Coleman (The Footwarmer and the Black Crow) complicates the story with some unnecessary subplots, the impact is strong. Geter's (Dawn and the Round-to-it) full- and double-page paintings can be hazy, but they conduct the story's considerable emotional charge. Ages 5-9. (Mar.)
Children's Literature
- Judy Katsh
The actions of a young girl confused by the "Whites Only" sign hanging from the town water fountain spark a confrontation that ultimately involves the whole town. The young girl's confusion while shared by the readers who may have as much trouble understanding the actual problem as they do understanding the laws of segregation themselves. Even though this story might require some explaining by adult reading partners, it's an important one that will help young children start thinking and talking about race relations in this country both historically and in the present.
Children's Literature
- Susie Wilde
Evelyn Coleman, a new and powerful voice in children's books, blends themes of injustice and magic with her special storytelling gift. During the Civil Rights era, a young black girl dresses up in her white Sunday best and, for the first time, she ventures into town alone to find out if you really can fry an egg on a sidewalk. She walks timidly past the Chicken Man, who's learned African magic from his grandmother, and might turn someone "who's not doing right" into a chicken. Mission accomplished, the parched child spots a drinking fountain that bears the sign, "Whites Only". She takes off her black shoes, and now, dressed only in white, begins to drink. When a white man begins to whip the young girl, her innocence inspires those around her to remove their shoes and drink from the fountain as well, including the Chicken Man who tells her she "done good."
School Library Journal
Gr 2-4In this story, a grandmother relates an incident from her childhood to her granddaughter. On a scorching hot Mississippi day, a little girl walks into town by herself to learn whether it really is possible to fry an egg on the sidewalk. Mission accomplished, she is on her way home when she stops for a drink of water. Interpreting the "whites only" sign on the water fountain to refer to socks, the African American child takes off her patent-leather shoes and has just begun to drink when an angry white man grabs her and pushes her to the ground. He threatens to "whup" her, but the black townspeople come to the girl's aid by taking off their shoes and drinking from the same fountain. The angry bigot then receives punishment at the hands of a local conjure man. Atmospheric paintings, smudged and moody, will draw readers into this gripping tale. However, the story has some unsettling elements. The protagonist is old enough to go into town alone, yet she is oblivious to the meaning of the "whites only" sign. Her certainty that the sign refers to white socks is also curious; knowing that is what it means implies some prior knowledge, but she clearly does not have the facts straight.Anna DeWind, Milwaukee Public Library
