Books.org participates in affiliate programs including Bookshop.org and the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page, at no additional cost to you.
Overview
Why? is a book about the explanations we give and how we give them--a fascinating look at the way the reasons we offer every day are dictated by, and help constitute, social relationships. Written in an easy-to-read style by distinguished social historian Charles Tilly, the book explores the manner in which people claim, establish, negotiate, repair, rework, or terminate relations with others through the reasons they give.
Tilly examines a number of different types of reason giving. For example, he shows how an air traffic controller would explain the near miss of two aircraft in several different ways, depending upon the intended audience: for an acquaintance at a cocktail party, he might shrug it off by saying "This happens all the time," or offer a chatty, colloquial rendition of what transpired; for a colleague at work, he would venture a longer, more technical explanation, and for a formal report for his division head he would provide an exhaustive, detailed account.
Tilly demonstrates that reasons fall into four different categories:
- Convention: "I'm sorry I spilled my coffee; I'm such a klutz."
- Narratives: "My friend betrayed me because she was jealous of my sister."
- Technical cause-effect accounts: "A short circuit in the ignition system caused the engine rotors to fail."
- Codes or workplace jargon: "We can't turn over the records. We're bound by statute 369."
Tilly illustrates his topic by showing how a variety of people gave reasons for the 9/11 attacks. He also demonstrates how those who work with one sort of reason frequently convert it into another sort. For example, a doctor might understand an illness using the technical language of biochemistry, but explain it to his patient, who knows nothing of biochemistry, by using conventions and stories.
Replete with sparkling anecdotes about everyday social experiences (including the author's own), Why? makes the case for stories as one of the great human inventions.
Editorials
Publishers Weekly
Frustrated that his explanations of contemporary phenomena-which emphasized incremental effects and complex social interactions-often failed to convince people, Columbia sociologist Tilly decided to write this odd but intermittently charming analysis of the reasons people use to explain events or behavior. He lists four basic types of reasons: conventions (socially accepted clich s like "My train was late," or "We're otherwise engaged that evening"), stories (simplified cause-effect narratives), codes (legal, religious) and technical accounts (complicated narratives, often impenetrable to nonspecialists). He demonstrates that our social relations dictate the kind of reason we invoke in a given circumstance. For instance, we offer more elaborate rationales for our behavior-stories, rather than conventions-to those close to us. We invoke codes with individuals whom we have power over, but not those who have power over us. But these insights, which he acknowledges are hardly original, also seem beside the point. Tilly's true interest lies in how social scientists can make their theories accessible and persuasive. Using Jared Diamond and terrorism expert Jessica Stern as examples of specialists who have successfully popularized their ideas, Tilly reaches the unsurprising conclusion that experts may need to simplify or narrow the scope of their accounts in order to reach the public. The result is an uneven little book-occasionally arresting, sometimes irritatingly random. (Apr.) Copyright 2006 Reed Business Information.Library Journal
This book is the result of Tilly's (social science, Columbia Univ.; The Politics of Collective Violence) wondering "why people give the reasons they do for what they have done, for what others have done to them, or more generally for what goes on in the world," an issue about which most people have probably wondered. He examines four overlapping categories of reason-giving-conventions, stories, codes, and technical accounts-and considers highly charged situations of topical interest, e.g., the 9/11 terrorist attacks, medical emergencies, religion, abortion, contraception, accidents, legal conflicts, crimes, scientific debates, etiquette, and even the Kennedy assassination. In all of these, Tilly finds that the relations between persons giving and asking for reasons are more important than psychological or philosophical considerations. (He is not concerned with the validity of the reasons given.) He argues convincingly that reason-giving always takes place in a social setting structured by the social relations of the persons in that setting. This eminently readable and interesting book should find a place in public and academic library collections.-Leon H. Brody, U.S. Office of Personnel Management Lib., Washington, DC Copyright 2006 Reed Business Information.PsycCRITIQUES
Tilly gives us . . . a good read, a book that calls our attention to a prevalent human phenomenon and raises the importance of investigating its nature. . . . The book also suggests that we sit down and begin to examine the nature of reason giving in our society—why we spend so much of our time doing it, what effect it has on our social relations, and . . . what effect it has on our own behavior and emotions.— Kurt Salzinger
European Legacy
Tilly's book is insightful, easily accessible to any audience and worth reading.— Richard Findler
PsycCritiques
Tilly gives us . . . a good read, a book that calls our attention to a prevalent human phenomenon and raises the importance of investigating its nature. . . . The book also suggests that we sit down and begin to examine the nature of reason giving in our society--why we spend so much of our time doing it, what effect it has on our social relations, and . . . what effect it has on our own behavior and emotions.
— Kurt Salzinger
New Yorker
In the tradition of the legendary sociologist Erving Goffman, Tilly seeks to decode the structure of everyday social interaction, and the result is a book that forces readers to reexamine everything from the way they talk to their children to the way they argue about politics.— Malcolm Gladwell
London Review of Books
[A] persuasive book. . . . It is obvious that the cancer specialist talks differently to his colleagues from the way he talks to his patients: exactly what he might be doing in talking differently is Tilly's concern.— Adam Phillips
Culture Wars
We need to impose order on chaos, not by disregarding complicated realities, but by understanding what those complicated realities mean for us. Why? is a stimulating contribution to our thinking about this problem.— Dolan Cummings
Journal of Peace Research
While Why? may be a frustrating read to the social scientist looking for methodological innovation, it is warmly recommended for anybody who is simply curious about the central role of reason giving.— Kristian Berg Harpviken